michael’s posterous

« Back to blog

Blog: Legally, why I can't stream or podcast from a legal angle

Hello, friends. Since I've been back on the radio, the number one question I get asked via emails, Twitter, blog notes, on air phone calls, and from folks who live within radio reception of WGMDfm:

"How come you're not on the internet? All the other shows from WGMD are...and how come you just don't podcast?"

Answer:
Because when I left my contract with CBS radio in February, 2008, they still held my "rights" until the orginial contract end date of October, 2010.
That's the only way they would let me out of the deal.
I won't go into the tale again of why I needed a change, and how wonderful my life is now. 
But I needed to stop, slow down, and re-establish my life. The only way CBS would allow me an early release was a "non-compete" contract, valid until October, 2010.
It states I can work on the radio NO WHERE in America expect the Salisbury/Ocean City, Md. market. That's it. 
It also states NO internet streaming or podcasting. 

It also matters not that WJFK's format has changed, or any other radio moves that do or don't concern me directly. The deal clearly states the Non-Compete is first and foremost for the Washington, D.C. market. ALL stations, owned by anyone. Regardless of format.

It's a crappy deal. I have not been paid a dime  from CBS since I stepped away.
And I walked away from some big bucks that most likely will never pass my way again. 
I accepted it because I knew I needed to step away and get my life in order.
I know the deal I made with the CBS devil,  I have signed off on the deal, and I will honor it.

But I still get bombarded with questions about it. So let's go to a very respected and highly paid (by ME!) lawyer to answer the three main questions I still get:

QUESTION #1:
What is a non-compete? 

A covenant not to compete is a promise by an employee not to compete with his or her employer for a specified time, in a particular place or in a particular way. A covenant not to compete, which is also known as a non-competition agreement, may be a clause in an employment agreement or a separate contract standing by itself.

QUESTION #2:
Come on, are these things really enforced?
Generally speaking, yes. Courts once did not enforce non competition agreements, viewing them as unlawful restraints on competition.  Today, however, courts will enforce non-competition agreements if:
  • the employer proves that it has a legitimate business interest to protect by restricting its employees' right to compete against it;
  • the restriction on the employee's right to compete is no greater than that necessary to protect the employer's business interest; and
  • the covenant not to compete is supported by consideration, meaning that the employee received something in exchange for it.
Every case turns on its own facts. Judges who enforce a non-competition agreement must balance the protection of the employer's business interest against the employee's right to earn a living, as well as other factors, such as whether the restrictions will harm the public. 

 QUESTION #3:
 Why don't you just turn on the stream, or make your own 
 podcast? Why don't you just try and break the contract?
 What could happen?

Plenty, and not much of it good.  First, your employer can file suit against you for an injunction and money damages.  If the employer can point to a facially valid agreement and reasonable restrictions, most courts will grant an injunction while the lawsuit is pending.  You will have to hire an attorney to defend the suit and, when it is over, you not only may owe the money damages sought by the employer, but may be prevented from competing for a period of time following the lawsuit.

Another tactic for the former employer is to threaten your new employer with a lawsuit for "tortious interference" with the non-competition agreement between you and your old employer. If your non-compete is valid, then a third party who induces you to break it can face the same liability as you, and possiby more.  To avoid this liability, the new employer will often terminate the new employee, which it is free to do.

Hope this helps answer those questions. I know it's all very complicated. IF there were a way out, I'd be there already.

I appreciate all the support.
I also know that everyone who communicates with me thinks it should be easy to get around this agreement, which I signed.
I can't, until one year from October.

Which is pretty close. 
It would be nice to have my show on WGMD be available on the ole interwebs, but that deal will change in about a year.

Are we cool? 
Danke!

d.
August 11, 2009

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (35)

Aug 11, 2009
monicaindc said...
Sorry that you are being bombarded with the same questions over and over. I think a lot of us are just incredibly frustrated with everything that has happened. It was hard to lose you, after so many years. But at least we still had Mike and the boys... they really did have a good thing going. There is truly NOTHING worth listening to on afternoon DC radio. I got Sirius, which I said I'd NEVER do, but I did... just to try to find something worth listening to on my long ass drive home every day. The tweets are a jonez but at least you're still out there and HAPPY!!! Looking forward to Oct 2010. Miss ya much!
Aug 11, 2009
Chalkycolon said...
Cant wait for Oct 2010 to get here and what is this internets yee speak of ?
Aug 11, 2009
Finsperfect72 said...
Yep, it's a crappy deal and CBS gains nothing by forcing you to abide by it. Fortunately, I've got just enough patience to get me through 10/10. Until then, I'll enjoy your Tweets and blogs and the occasional bubble tweet (or whatever the hell they're called) to tide me over until you're back on LIVE. Miss you and love you, DG.
Aug 11, 2009
 said...
Hey Don,

Could you ask your lawyer to opine publicly on why it might be "necessary to protect [CBS's] business interest" to stop you from broadcasting in or to markets where CBS doesn't own any radio stations? I can (maybe) understand their interest in not having you on the air in the 29 markets where they own stations, but what about the rest of the country?

If you need me to testify on "whether the restrictions will harm the public," I will be happy to do so. WE MISS YOU! :)

Aug 11, 2009
Don Geronimo said...
It is the way it is because that is how CBS wrote it. Please folks, no more questions like this guy's. They wrote me a non compete for everywhere in the USA because they had all the leverage. They didn't want me to go, so they made it a fool's deal to accept. I took it, because it was the only fucking way I could get out.

Jesus, it matters not IF you understand the agreement or not. It is the law of the land until next October.

Sorry for the swear, but seriously, folks. Like my lawyer(s) haven't tried every possible avenue open to me?????????????????????????????

Still, I thank you, last poster, for your support.

Aug 11, 2009
 said...
Sorry, Don. But I'm a member of the public and I'm being harmed out here! :)

Now that the truth is out there, no more questions. See you on my Blackberry in 14 months.

(IAAL and, naturally, a PITA, BTW, so I like to poke. And don't worry about the swearing because, like most good lawyers, I could be a guest on Jew 2 Jew).

Aug 11, 2009
cjecar said...
All that matters is that you are happy and it is very evident that you are. I can wait til Oct 2010.
Aug 11, 2009
Don Geronimo said...
Finsperfect72: CBS has lots to gain by keeping me off the air. That means I'm not making $$$ and ratings for the competition. If they didn't feel that way, as much of a pain in the ass as I am, they'd let me go ASAP. Let me be someone's problem, so to speak.
I will be CBS radio's problem, as some sort of competitor, soon enough.
Pep talk over!
Aug 11, 2009
Andrea Gidusko said...
I've been listening to you since I was 13. 1988. Your voice was the first voice I heard in the morning...and sometimes you were letting out a giant burp or fart but I loved it and all the other memories you have brought me for the last 20 years give or take the few I missed when I moved to LA then to Denver but then I had the stream and I loved that stream. I will follow you in tweets I will follow you in blogs and come 2010 I will rejoice when I have Doni G back. Bodily noises and all. Be happy Doni. That's all a true fan should want.
Aug 11, 2009
big1ron said...
That is the worst deal ever. Nice, Don. Let's see... they pay you NOTHING. And you have no chance to EARN ANYTHING except in tiny Delmarva.... were you high when you signed that? Did your lawyer laugh at you when you showed it to him?
Aug 11, 2009
Don Geronimo said...
big1ron: I have nothing but my giant stacks of cash to keep me company until I return to the workplace. The chance to get my life together was worth anything. I don't need to work, I was blessed to be rewarded financially enough to take a break.
I disagree. It was the BEST deal ever. I got my life back.
And I'm happy in "tiny Delmarva".

Now piss off.

Aug 11, 2009
 said...
Goddamn it. I guess my stock pile of D&M MP3s will have to hold me over until then. Fucking CBS - give 'em hell Donny.
Aug 11, 2009
jaoll said...
I listened nearly ever day for over 14 years. I can get thorugh 14 months. The Sopranos had longer hiatuses.
Aug 11, 2009
Chalkycolon said...
Don , do you still carry the title of worlds dumbest millionaire ?
Another fantastic show today!
Aug 11, 2009
JMyers15 said...
Don, All that matters is that your life is back in order. You are well worth the wait to hear again.
Aug 12, 2009
 said...
Why don't you just use the good old-fashioned Don & Mike TIME MACHINE!?!?!?

Don't you just love the booger eaters? If they ask enough times, maybe you'll change your mind? Jeez!

Aug 12, 2009
Ripwally said...
Don- "Tiny Delmarva" is damn happy to have you too. Contentment in ones life often comes with a price.
Aug 12, 2009
Chad Bewley said...
Don- Thanks for the posts and tweets. Due to weird atmospheric conditions (sun spots?) I have been able to hear an episode or 2 here in Boise. Keep up the good work.
Aug 12, 2009
rvm said...
Time goes by fast, it'll be October 2010 before you know it. We can wait.
Aug 12, 2009
Andrea said...
It's sad that you had to explain yourself on this one, but maybe you'll stop getting so much heat for it now. I think most of us realize that you WOULD be streaming online if you COULD. For christs sake those big babies need to chill out - I also miss listening to you on the air, but I also know that YOU aren't trying to deprive anyone of anything, so they can lay off the guilt and 100 questions. You have more thoughtfulness for your fans than that. Hindsight is 20/20 on contracts. No one really knows what is going to happen long term...sometimes they work out great and sometimes they don't. I don't think any lesser of you for this so called 'devil's contract'. On the other hand, the big suits on the other side of this contract can just go suck it. They are going to be sweating it hard when you come back in 2010.

Thanks for sticking with your blog even though you are back on the air!

Aug 12, 2009
Kevin Harding said...
Everyone just piss off LEAVE DON ALONE ( BRITNEY TO )

from: Oscars number one fan

Aug 12, 2009
 said...
Not a comment on the blog, but a note to thank you again for all your years on the air as the 'shock jock' everybody loved to hate. I just listened again to your final JFK show and I can't tell you how nice it was for you to let us all peek behind the curtain, however briefly. If you should ever return to the DC airwaves, know that I'll be tuned in from day one.

Also, I gained an odd and maybe surprising thing from your old show which you might appreciate. Your relationship with your son was so warm and honest, and it's served as a great example to me. My dad was much like yours appears to have been, so I could use all the help I could get. It's never far from my mind when I'm with my own now 9-year old son and we're each other's best friends. You helped make that happen, so thanks for that as well.

-J

"...just people."

Aug 12, 2009
sw0rdfish said...
And that, Don, is why I was so happy that our family vacation took us from Kansas to Ocean City, and I got to lie there on the beach (unless I was laying there on the beach), ear plugs in, laughing like a loon, with a big dopey smile on my face. Not that it'll hold me for another 14 months, but I sure did enjoy it. As always, thanks for being my imaginary friend.
Aug 12, 2009
Henry Herman said...
Okay. Devil's advocate. What's to keep someone else, completely unconnected to you or the station, a regular Joe, from recording the show and posting it on, say, iTunes?
Aug 12, 2009
Chad Bewley said...
Henry- I think the lawyers at CBS would send you a nice letter threatening to sue you for lots of money.
Aug 12, 2009
JoeSaputo said...
We need a generous listener in Ocean City to tape the shows and post or email them privately to us. Don obviously can't be involved. Maybe? What do you say OC listeners share the wealth.
Aug 12, 2009
LaVikinga said...
Don, those of us who love you from afar know you did the right thing getting out when you did. The simple fact you've found Jan, recognized how wonderful she is AND that you've come back to broadcasting so soon proves the point.

Hope tomorrow's visit to JohnsHopkins is just for the ol' finger wave and your annual PSA check. (Although you ARE fast approaching the age for your first colonoscopy. Yeah, I know. It's an exit, NOT an entrance!) Good luck! And remember: just close your eyes and think of England!

Aug 12, 2009
patriot21842 said...
Don, your show is great. I think you will like this video: http://tiny.cc/ZH2Hm. Thanks, Pat in OC...
Aug 13, 2009
infobrokers said...
Long time listener = never time caller. Grew up listening to the radio and like you sometimes used radio to fill spaces between loneliness. You've been through a lot and your life is yours to do of as you wish and no one can tell you otherwise. I'm glad you've been able to share both your joys and sorrows through the years on the radio. As for myself, I've learned more about me in the last year than I have in the first 50. I suspect that with an adjustment of a few numbers perhaps you know of what I speak. No "man love" here - just the realization that you're at your basest - a simple man who only wants love and respect of his friends and family - and the ability to do what he loves best. May 2010 should be a good year for all of us.
Aug 14, 2009
 said...
I thought you couldn't legally podcast because YOU CRAPPED YOUR PANTS.
Aug 14, 2009
YASK24 said...
What Don is saying is no bullshit I was actually sued and was able to settle out of court. You do not want to get sued over something like this. It's no fun and very costly...
Aug 15, 2009
 said...
One year isn't that long. We can wait. You are worth it.
Aug 17, 2009
MatthewOpaliski said...
What does this have to do with listening the old fashioned way, I mean, I tune in daily right after Gaffney's Morning Zoo and get nothing, it's 97.2 FM right ?
Aug 18, 2009
starfoxxxx said...
hey Don, what's the name of the "laughing" song, your new theme song. I hope. It cracks me and the guys I work with up.
Aug 19, 2009
Mr_Angus said...
I'm in Texas and I miss being able to hear you when you were syndicated in Austin. I look forward to the day when you can podcast, and will be one of your first ..........whatever I'd be, listener, downloader......whatever, I'm there.

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     Connect     twitter